Nature Human Behaviour · 15 September 2026 · From issue 37
Defining collectivism as duties in relationships rather than generalized warmth improves predictive validity in 100 cultures
Asking about duty to family, not general warmth, reveals huge cultural differences that old surveys missed.
Thomas Talhelm, Liuqing Wei et al.
Old surveys asked people if they felt warm and caring toward everyone. That question could not tell cultures apart. A new question asked about duties to close family and friends instead. It found huge differences between 100 cultures, in a study of 12,247 people, and linked to things like corruption and family closeness.
Integrity screen: passed (3 checks) Checked 30 October 2026. Read the source
The plain-language reading of this paper is in the full issue, for subscribers.
Read the full issue