Open Access Publishing: The Models and Who Pays
Open access means a paper is free for anyone to read online, instead of sitting behind a journal paywall. The publishing itself still costs money, so that cost moves from the reader to someone else, usually the author, their university, or their funder, through a fee called an article processing charge.
What open access actually changes
Under the old model, readers or their libraries pay. A university subscribes to a journal bundle, and anyone outside that university hits a paywall. Open access flips this. The paper is published under a licence that lets anyone download, read, and often reuse it without paying a penny.
Nothing about peer review changes. An open access journal still sends the paper to outside experts who check the methods and conclusions before publication, in the same way a subscription journal does. The difference is entirely about who funds the publishing process and who can read the result afterwards.
That funding has to come from somewhere, because running a journal costs money even without printing. Editors need managing, typesetting and formatting need doing, servers need hosting, and plagiarism checks and basic quality control need staff. Open access does not remove these costs, it just moves who covers them.
The article processing charge explained
The article processing charge, usually shortened to APC, is a fee paid to publish a single paper in open access form. It is charged once the paper is accepted, not when it is submitted, so rejected papers do not cost the author anything.
APCs vary enormously. Some open access journals charge nothing at all, particularly smaller journals run by academic societies or universities. Others, especially those published by large commercial publishers with a strong reputation, charge fees that can run into several thousand pounds or dollars for a single article.
The fee is rarely paid by the researcher out of their own pocket. It usually comes from a research grant, where funders increasingly budget for publishing costs alongside lab equipment and salaries, or from a central fund held by the author's university library. Some funders, particularly in Europe, now require that any research they pay for must be published open access, and they expect the APC to be built into the grant from the start.
Gold, green, and hybrid routes
Gold open access is the version most people picture: the paper is published in an open access journal and is free to read from day one, funded by an APC. Green open access works differently. The paper is published in a normal subscription journal, but the author is also allowed to post a version, often the accepted manuscript before final formatting, in a free public repository.
Green open access usually involves no APC at all, because the publisher still earns money from subscriptions to the formal, formatted version. The trade-off is a delay, often six or twelve months, called an embargo, before the free repository copy can go live. During that window, only subscribers can read the official version.
Hybrid journals sit in between. They are ordinary subscription journals that also offer an open access option for individual articles, if the author pays an APC. Critics call this double dipping, because the publisher still collects subscription fees from libraries for the rest of the journal, while also collecting APCs for the open articles inside it. Several funders have pushed back against hybrid journals for this reason.
Who actually carries the cost
The simplest answer is that the cost moves from readers to writers, but it rarely lands on an individual writer directly. Well-funded researchers at well-funded universities, particularly in wealthier countries, usually have access to grant money or institutional funds that cover APCs without much friction.
Researchers without that backing face a real barrier. A scientist at a smaller university, in a country with less research funding, or working without a grant at all, may simply not be able to afford a journal's APC. Many journals offer fee waivers for researchers from lower income countries, but these are not universal and not always easy to obtain.
This creates an uncomfortable asymmetry. Open access was meant to make knowledge free for readers everywhere, including readers in poorer countries who could never afford journal subscriptions. But if publishing now costs thousands of pounds, it can simply shift the barrier from the reading side to the writing side, making it harder for less-funded researchers to get their own work published and seen.
Large research-intensive universities have responded by negotiating bulk deals with major publishers, sometimes called transformative agreements. Under these deals, the university pays one combined fee that covers both subscription access and a set number of open access publications for its researchers each year. This reduces the paperwork for individual authors, but it also concentrates a lot of the open access system around deals that only the biggest, richest institutions can strike.
Why this matters for readers
Why this matters for readers
If you read a paper and it is freely available, it does not mean the research was free to produce or publish. It means the cost was paid upfront by someone else, often a funding body using public money, so that the final reader does not have to pay again.
This matters when judging a journal's reputation too. A legitimate open access journal with proper peer review is doing the same careful work as any subscription journal. But the APC model has also attracted so-called predatory journals, which charge publication fees while skipping or faking the peer review process entirely. The existence of a fee is not a mark of quality in either direction, it simply tells you who paid for the paper to appear.
Common questions
- Are open access papers less trustworthy than paywalled ones?
Not inherently. Reputable open access journals run the same peer review process as subscription journals, checking methods and conclusions before publishing. The risk comes from predatory journals that charge an article processing charge without doing real peer review, so it pays to check a journal's standing rather than judging by access type alone.
- Can I read a paywalled paper for free some other way?
Often yes, through an author's own repository copy, a preprint version posted before peer review, or a request directly to the authors, who are usually happy to share their own work. These routes exist separately from the open access publishing model itself.
- Why do article processing charges vary so much between journals?
Pricing tends to track a journal's prestige and brand recognition rather than its actual production costs. A journal with a strong reputation and high rejection rate can charge more because researchers want their name attached to it, while smaller or newer journals charge less to attract submissions.
- Does open access mean I can reuse the text and figures freely?
It depends on the licence attached to the paper, not just on whether it is free to read. Many open access articles use a Creative Commons licence that allows reuse with attribution, but some only allow free reading while restricting copying or republishing, so it is worth checking the specific licence noted on the paper.
- Who decides if a funder requires open access publishing?
Research funders, including government agencies and large charitable foundations, set their own open access policies as a condition of accepting their grant money. Researchers agree to these terms when they apply for funding, and the funder's rules then determine which open access route, and sometimes which journals, are acceptable.
Lucent, once a week
We read the new research and write up what actually holds, in the same plain language as this page. No jargon, no hype, three papers a week.
Read the latest issueRead next
- What a Retraction Means and How to Check a Paper
A retraction is a journal's formal withdrawal of a published paper because its findings can no longer be trusted, and checking its status takes under a minute.
- Why Scientific Papers Are Paywalled, and How to Read Them Free
Researchers write and review papers for free, but publishers charge for access, though preprints and repositories let you read most papers legally at no cost.
- Journal Impact Factor: What It Measures and Why It's Hated
A journal's impact factor is the average number of citations its recent papers get, and many scientists say it measures the wrong thing entirely.